Wyniki sezonu 2023/2024
- 27/04/2024 East Grinstead Town 1 - 2Sheppey United Non League Div One - Isthmian South East
- 20/04/2024 Sheppey United 3 - 0Erith & Belvedere Non League Div One - Isthmian South East
- 16/04/2024 Burgess Hill Town 1 - 2Sheppey United Non League Div One - Isthmian South East
- 13/04/2024 Herne Bay 1 - 2Sheppey United Non League Div One - Isthmian South East
- 11/04/2024 Horndean 2 - 5Sheppey United Non League Div One - Isthmian South East
- 09/04/2024 Beckenham Town 4 - 2Sheppey United Non League Div One - Isthmian South East
- 06/04/2024 Sheppey United 5 - 1Ashford United Non League Div One - Isthmian South East
- 01/04/2024 Sheppey United 3 - 0Hythe Town Non League Div One - Isthmian South East
- 30/03/2024 Phoenix Sports 3 - 1Sheppey United Non League Div One - Isthmian South East
- 23/03/2024 Chichester City 2 - 0Sheppey United Non League Div One - Isthmian South East
- 16/03/2024 Sheppey United 0 - 2Cray Valley PM Non League Div One - Isthmian South East
- 09/03/2024 Sheppey United 3 - 4Sevenoaks Town Non League Div One - Isthmian South East
- 24/02/2024 Sheppey United 0 - 1Merstham Non League Div One - Isthmian South East
- 03/02/2024 Sheppey United 1 - 0Three Bridges Non League Div One - Isthmian South East
- 27/01/2024 Ramsgate 0 - 0Sheppey United Non League Div One - Isthmian South East